Arsenal's striker dilemma: who should lead the line?

For some time now, Arsenal’s most glaring weakness has been their lack of a natural number nine. Transfer windows have come and gone without the Gunners securing the prolific striker they desperately need, despite clear intentions to address the issue.

A late attempt to sign Ollie Watkins in January demonstrated the club’s urgency to strengthen their forward line. However, the failure to land the Aston Villa striker left Arsenal with Kai Havertz and Gabriel Jesus as their primary options. Neither is a traditional centre-forward, and with both currently sidelined due to injuries, the task of leading the attack has fallen to an unlikely stand-in—midfielder Mikel Merino.

With the summer transfer window now officially scheduled, Mikel Arteta looks set to finally receive the attacking reinforcement he has long desired. Three names have emerged as Arsenal’s primary targets: Alexander Isak, Viktor Gyokeres, and Benjamin Sesko. Each forward possesses the physicality and goal-scoring ability the club is seeking, but which player should Arsenal prioritize?

Alexander Isak: the proven Premier League star

Newcastle United’s Alexander Isak has already proven to be a thorn in Arsenal’s side, scoring in two of their three encounters this season. The Swedish international’s ability to trouble top-tier defenders is well documented, and his performances have earned comparisons to Thierry Henry.

With a lean yet imposing physique, explosive acceleration, and clinical finishing, Isak embodies everything defenders fear in a striker. His movement off the ball and ability to get in behind defensive lines make him a constant threat, and his efficiency in front of goal has only improved since arriving in England.

Having adapted seamlessly to the Premier League, Isak holds an advantage over his fellow targets. His debut season tally of ten goals was followed by an impressive 21 strikes in the previous campaign. He is currently on course to surpass that mark again, underlining his consistency and reliability.

Still just 25, Isak has already demonstrated his ability to trouble elite defenders such as William Saliba and Virgil van Dijk. With his prime years ahead of him, his ceiling remains frighteningly high. However, Newcastle’s valuation—rumored to be around £150m—could prove to be a significant obstacle.

Viktor Gyokeres: the goalscoring machine

Viktor Gyokeres has been in sensational form since leaving England for Sporting CP. Brighton & Hove Albion’s decision to let him go for just £1m in 2021 now looks like a costly error, as the Swedish forward has since evolved into one of Europe’s deadliest strikers.

After an impressive spell at Coventry City, Gyokeres has reached new heights in Portugal, scoring 43 goals last season and leading Sporting to the league title. His form has not dipped this term, with 40 goals in 41 appearances—a staggering level of productivity.

Gyokeres fits Arsenal’s search for a strong, athletic forward. His upper body strength allows him to hold off defenders, while his speed and intelligent movement make him a constant danger. Equally adept at linking up play and attacking space, he would provide the Gunners with a multifaceted threat.

With a contract running until 2028, Sporting are in no rush to part with their star striker. Any deal for Gyokeres would require a significant financial commitment, but given his track record, Arsenal would be investing in a proven goal machine.

Benjamin Sesko: the rising star

Of the three targets, Benjamin Sesko is the least established but arguably the most intriguing. The RB Leipzig forward, just 21 years old, has the potential to develop into a dominant force in European football. However, he is still refining his game, and patience may be required.

Sesko emerged from the Red Bull talent pipeline and was on Arsenal’s radar even before Euro 2024. After netting 18 goals last season, he is on track to better that tally this year, though his numbers do not yet match those of Isak or Gyokeres.

Standing at 6’5, Sesko boasts extraordinary pace for his size, along with a powerful shot. He may not yet possess the complete skill set of Arsenal’s other targets, but his ceiling is undeniably high. Given his age and potential, he is likely to be the most affordable of the three options.

Final decision: Isak stands out

Arsenal would be making a strong addition with any of these three strikers, but Isak appears to be the best option. His unique combination of physical presence, technical skill, and proven Premier League experience sets him apart.

Isak’s ability to excel against elite defenders and his consistent output in English football make him a prime candidate to lead Arsenal’s attack. The only major drawback is his hefty price tag, which could test the club’s financial resolve.

If Arsenal are willing to make a marquee investment, Isak could be the transformative signing they need to mount a serious title challenge. However, if the financial demands prove excessive, Gyokeres and Sesko offer exciting alternatives, each bringing their own strengths to the table.